A tale of two photographs

I found two photographs of politicians in classrooms this week. I was struck by the similarities – and differences – between them.

Photo 19-05-2013 10 21 34

The Secretary of State for Education looks awkward as he leans forward on his chair, off balance, as though he could fall any moment. His hand is cupped around his ear in an exaggerated attempt to make out what the children are saying. He towers above the children, trying to bring himself down to their level but unable to do so. He wears his jacket as though his visit is only fleeting. His expression is clownish and self-conscious. The girl nearest to him is amused by this funny man in her classroom, knowing that he isn’t really listening but is putting on a show for the benefit of the cameras. The other children don’t know how to react; they want to do the right thing and look beyond the frame for help and guidance.

President Barack Obama visiting Moravia Park Elementary School in Baltimore

The President commands respect as he leans back in his chair, stable and relaxed. His hand is raised in the air in an exaggerated attempt to provide the right answer to a question. He towers above the children, but is acting as one of them. His jacket is off and shirtsleeves rolled up as though he is settled in to the lesson. His expression is earnest and intent. The boy nearest to him is amused at this funny man in his classroom, knowing that he has the answer but is putting on a show for the benefit of the cameras. The other children don’t know how to react; they want to do the right thing and look beyond the frame for help and guidance.

I don’t know whether this juxtaposition says more about the superiority of American politicians in manufacturing a photo-op, or more about the superiority of this particular American politician. What I do know is that Michael Gove looks ridiculous, and Barack Obama looks…great.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s